14 Comments
User's avatar
Jess, The Creator's avatar

David's audit made me realize something: I've been paying attention to getting new subscribers, but I haven't thought nearly as much about what happens after they arrive.

Now I'm curious about everyone else's approach.

When someone new follows or subscribes to your Substack, what happens next?

Do you send a personal DM, rely on your welcome email, or let them explore on their own?

I'd love to hear what's actually working for other publishers.

Let's compare notes in the comments!

Danielle Wright's avatar

Wow wow!!! This was SO SO good. This isn’t talked about enough!! Definitely taking these tips! Thanks Jess and David!!!

David Roy's avatar

Thanks Danielle! Trying to get a bit more of the word out there. Appreciate the feedback, if you have any follow-up questions let me know!

Also huge thanks to Jess for letting me walk through this with her!

Jess, The Creator's avatar

Thanks again for coming on, David!! This was a very informative live for us!

Jess, The Creator's avatar

You’re so welcome, Danielle!! I’m glad the live was helpful!! Thank you for tuning in! David is awesome!

Colette Simone's avatar

Goodness I have such a block against sending followers DM’s. I think it’s because I am the kind of person if I walk into a physical shop and the sales person even talks to me before I am ready I am right out the door again. I suppose it all depends on your tone.

David Roy's avatar

Thanks for sharing Colette. I would say it really is a mindset shift for the most part.

One of the reasons I like the problem solving approach is I’m an engineer by training. 🤣

But the other big reason is it changes my approach from “oh I have to sell this to them” to “I’m helping them get a little better each day”.

I hope our conversation was helpful to you. If you ever have any follow-up questions please feel free to reach out.

Colette Simone's avatar

Very helpful thanks

Jess, The Creator's avatar

I can totally relate, Colette! I used to feel like that too. I could say I used to have a mental block with sales and marketing but I have come a long way. I also still have some blocks I think.

Colette Simone's avatar

Just a little feedback - this went through the survey really fast for those of us that know zero about Sales, I think the thing I am getting out of it with the customer engagement, is once they have engaged - how are you ensuring that they not only get to the point where they pay but where they really are getting the extra things that are going to make this not generic and just completely right for them themselves. so more personal touch stuff.

Colette Simone's avatar

I really love this flywheel model and building the community

Colette Simone's avatar

Ooh this is exciting

!

Melanie R. Jordan NBC-HWC's avatar

This was an excellent share of your audit Jess. Having been in sales, I completely agree that "no" should always be considered not necessarily that it's forever. I've had people become paid subscribers who are among my most loyal and engaged, as well as people who I have never heard one comment from. I'm still figuring out what makes people say "yes" on Substack.

It's interesting David mentioned the DMs. I've gotten some of those obviously automated DMs for being a new subscriber or follower from others and they felt a bit corny and contrived to me. I do think I can do more with followers but I have to figure out what is scalable and what feels authentic to me.

You've both given me some additional food for thought as I have time :)